articles by Category
The Forms You Need

One of the advantages of being a member of BPOA is having access to a wide array of useful forms, some of which have been created just for our members. For example, The BPOA RENTAL AGREEMENT F09 is specific to Berkeley and includes lead, asbestos and sex offender language. You can view the complete list of available forms here, but only members can download.

BPOA Article Library

Only in Berkeley • November 1, 2005

Giant Victory for a Man, Small Victory for Mankind?

Giant Victory for a Man, Small Victory for Mankind?

 

Heartfelt congratulations go to BPOA Board member Jim Smith, who recently defeated the rent board in Superior Court.  His experience revealed the absolute hubris of the Rent Board and City when it comes to litigation.  Even when they’re wrong, they’ll do almost anything to exact a pound of flesh from the poor soul who is in the right.  Their litigation strategy is ripped right from the playbook of the largest, nastiest corporations in America.

 

And remember: they’re using your money to do it.

 

Here’s the short version of Jim’s story.  Waaaay back before 1999, during the Costa-Hawkins phase-in period, Jim had a vacancy.  The departing tenant had been Section 8, paying rent of X.  So Jim charged the next tenant X plus 15%, which is exactly what the law allowed between 1996 and 1999.  Jim was extra certain of that because he’d been involved in drafting that part of Costa-Hawkins in the first place.

 

The rent board, of course, had its own “interpretation,” which was that Section 8 rents just don’t count.  Therefore, Jim could only charge 15% more than the last non-Section 8 tenant paid, however long ago that was.  They ordered rent refunds.

 

In court, the judge didn’t hesitate to reject the board’s “interpretation” of state law.  But if that seems like a simple matter, you’re wrong.  The total amount at issue was perhaps $4000—a nothing to the rent board, but a sizable amount to Jim.  Yet the cost of proving the Rent Board wrong was over $30,000!  (Fortunately, most of the cost has been covered by contributions from many generous landlords.)

 

Legally, Jim was entitled to make the rent board pay those costs.  That’s when the Board engaged in its favorite tactic:  blackmail.  Essentially, the Board threatened to appeal its dead-bang-loser case (costing tens of thousands more dollars and upping the ante, so to speak) unless Jim agreed to give up his right to recover his costs.  To add insult to injury, the Board also made Jim agree to a “payment plan” for the tenant.  You see, the tenant had already been given permission to “withhold” the $4000.  And the tenant had spent it all, leaving nothing to pay back to Jim.

 

Sadly, the Rent Board takes the simple position that it can do anything it wants, whether legal or not, because few landlords will spend the money to prove the Board wrong.  The City itself takes a similar approach.  In the lawsuit to set aside the City/UC settlement (see the editorial on page 2), two recent court cases indicate that the City is just plain wrong.  But rather than concede the futility of further litigation, the City told the plaintiffs that it would simply spend them into the ground, filing motions and appeals until the plaintiffs give up. 

 

That’s why victories like Jim’s are important.  His $4000 means the world to him, and little for the rest of us.  But righting a wrong is a victory for us all.

JOIN OUR MAILING LIST

Receive event reminders, news & alerts from BPOA.
You don't have to be a member to sign up!

EVENTS

September 17
Illegal Units...Everything you Wanted to Know, but Were Afraid to Ask

View the Calendar...

FREE DOWNLOAD

BPOA Monthly Newsletter

Another advantage of being a member of BPOA is that you will receive our monthly print newsletter. From news and political reports to articles and advice, we cover the state and local issues you need to know about as a housing provider in Berkeley.
Get your complimentary copy of a recent issue of the BPOA Monthly Right Here .

    Home    About BPOA    Articles    Calendar    Available Forms    Q&A    Resources    Members    Get in Touch    Join    Renew!    Sitemap    
BPOA • 2041 BANCROFT WAY SUITE 203 • BERKELEY, CA 94704
Voice 510.525.3666 • Fax 510.525.0203 • ©2014 Berkeley Property Owners Association. All Rights Reserved.